Why Most Feedback Tools Fail to Capture What Users Really Mean

Most companies collect customer feedback. Very few actually understand it.

Text areas, quick surveys, and rating scales are everywhere. Yet teams still walk away from feedback unsure what users were trying to say, what problem they were facing and other important details they would need to know to fix it.

The issue isn’t that users don’t have opinions. It’s that most feedback tools aren’t designed to listen.

The illusion of “collecting feedback”

In most products, feedback collection looks the same: a short form, a few multiple-choice questions, maybe one open text field at the end.

On paper, that should work, that's how we have been taught.

In practice, users are busy. They’re trying to close a tab, finish a task, or move on with their day. When asked for feedback, they give the shortest possible answer that lets them continue.

That’s how you end up with responses like:

“Confusing.”
“Didn’t work for us.”
“Missing features.”

The moment the form is submitted, the conversation ends — and with it, any chance to understand what the user actually meant.

Why vague feedback is worse than no feedback

Consider a simple example.

You ask users for feedback after they try the free trial of your new SEO tool. One response reads:

“Bad. No integration to our CRM.”

At first glance, that seems clear. But almost immediately, questions appear.

Which CRM? Why is the integration important? What workflow are they trying to support? Is the lack of integration the real problem, or just the most visible symptom?

Maybe they don’t actually need an integration at all. Maybe they’re trying to report SEO performance internally, or connect data to sales outcomes. Solve that underlying problem differently, and you might create far more value than a simple integration ever could.

Traditional feedback tools stop too early to reveal any of this.

Feedback works better as a conversation

Good feedback isn’t about asking more questions upfront.
It’s about asking the right follow-up questions at the right moment.

When a user gives a vague or incomplete answer, the most valuable thing you can do is respond with curiosity:

“What do you mean by that?”
“Why was that important to you?”
“What were you trying to achieve?”

This is how human interviews work — and it’s why interviews produce insights that surveys rarely do.

The problem is that interviews don’t scale.

Using SelkoDialog to collect richer feedback

SelkoDialog treats feedback collection as a short, guided conversation rather than a static form.

You start by defining what you want to understand — for example, why users didn’t convert, what frustrated them, or what they were hoping to accomplish. From there, the AI agent takes over.

When a user gives an unclear or high-level response, SelkoDialog automatically asks follow-up questions to dig deeper. The conversation adapts based on what the user says, continuing until the intent and context become clear.

Instead of stopping at “No CRM integration,” you learn what the user actually needed — and why.

Simple for users, automated for teams

From the user’s perspective, nothing feels heavy. They click a link, answer a few questions, and move on. There’s no scheduling, no calls, no friction.

From your side, feedback collection runs on autopilot. You can share the conversation link in an email, place it inside your app, or trigger it at specific moments — like after a trial ends or a feature is used.

The result is feedback that explains itself.

From opinions to understanding

Surveys are good at telling you what users think. Conversations are how you learn why.

If you’re collecting plenty of feedback but still struggling to make confident decisions, the problem isn’t a lack of data. It’s a lack of depth.

SelkoDialog helps bridge that gap by turning feedback into a conversation — one that doesn’t end until the important questions are answered.

Get started today and try collecting feedback through a conversation instead of a form.

Ready to revolutionize your user research? Sign up for free and get your first 3 interview credits.